CIP Editors are members of the GitHub team — CIP. Their role is strictly administrative and editorial; they do not judge the technical merits of a proposal, but ensure it meets the repository's standards for quality and structure.
For every new CIP submission, an editor is responsible for:
- Technical Coherence: Reviewing the CIP to ensure it is sound, comprehensive, and technically coherent.
- Accuracy: Ensuring the title accurately describes the content.
- Quality Control: Reviewing spelling, grammar, sentence structure, GitHub-flavored Markdown markup, and code style.
If a CIP does not meet these standards, the editor returns it to the author with specific revision instructions.