Compare Foreach vs Regular Optimizer performance
mainThe pytorch_optimizer library supports foreach implementations for its optimizers. Using foreach=True typically provides a speedup in execution time on CUDA devices by utilizing vectorized operations, though it may increase peak memory usage.
Based on benchmarks using an MLP model (29M parameters) on an NVIDIA GeForce GTX 1060, the average speedup for foreach implementations is approximately 1.13x.
Key Trade-offs:
- Speed: Most optimizers (e.g.,
AdaFactor,Lion,SGDW) show significant speedups (ranging from 1.1x to 1.3x). - Memory:
foreachoften results in higher peak memory consumption (e.g.,AdaFactorsaw a +75.3% increase). Some optimizers likeLARSandSGDWshow 0.0% memory difference. - Exceptions: Some optimizers like
AdanandADOPTmay perform slightly slower or show increased memory overhead when usingforeach.